Vermont:

The point is not whether my concept of a truce is correct. The point is that there is no universally-held concept of a truce, so there can be no universally-held concept of offenses involving truces, particularly bannable ones.

Operationally, a truce, or even a mere flag, becomes an alliance if it is countered.

My assessment of Bone-rollers ban is a player should not be banned for failing to make clear that he has truced another player.

superxchloe, i dont know are you bone roller alt, his friend or you just try to suck up to this retarded incompetent damn moronbut he is first MOD who got disaproved and who manage to disagree and get disaproval from 3 mod's, what that tell's you??? And in the mean time I asked around, I am not first guy who get into conflict with this idiot, so there is only 2 options: 1. he is totaly retarded and incompetent
2. he solve his personal conflicts with help of MOD stats.

In both cases this retard should be removed from position what he cant preform on decent and proper way, so w dont need to say anything else, remove this damn noob from administrator position for good of comunity.

im pretty sure that skrum is the longest tenured MOD around here and his word should mean something...i too have no personal investment in this but i agree that this ban was a stupid one from what it sounds like

skrum, you made very specific statements as to what truces and alliances were. I was merely pointing out that a majority of players would disagree with your definition of a truce, albeit in less than friendly fashion.

For a player that argues that there isn't an accepted definition, you sure tried to put yours out there.

I imagine this will be like the TAZD discussion where you stubbornly refused to budge in the least, though.

i agree with verm-- if someone truced me, but left me to die with the understanding that all our truce entitled him is to not hit me (and not to ally/protect me), i would definitely feel stabbed...

yeah lj but if I as your truce partner lag out and give you first cause i have largest dom, would you call that point funeling??

I see that I have limited sarcasm detection powers. BR said in a reply I missed that he was tongue in cheek about the truce detection thingie.

AND SO, YOU WILL LEAVE THIS BAN AFTER ALL THIS PEOPLE AND 3 MODS DISAGREE WITH THAT DECISION???
10 PEOPLE'S AND 3 MODS DISAPROVE THIS BAN AND YOU WILL LEAVE IT CAUSE 'WE DON'T GO AGAINST EACH OTHER' POLICY??? Damn this is so messed up... Thrax? Someone? Plz make right thing and remove this ban and educate this damn noob how to do his work or kick him out of team!

i know im late to disagree, but mods shouldn't be able to compete chloe...for the same reason that doctors arent allowed to perform surgery on family members and why lawyers cant enter business agreements with their clients...conflict of interest

i see that bone roller banned ceban on september 21st for "PGA" with King85...this is a player that played in only 13 games that month with a -69 PPG...this seems pretty retarded. i think that most people would agree on this