Forum
I have fully demolished the thought process of deductive reasoning.
|
Cambria wrote
at 2:32 PM, Thursday February 4, 2010 EST
I can create two contradictory arguments, using 3 sound arguments.
A. 1) I like cookies. 2) thin mints are cookies. 3) I like thin mints. B. 1) I do not like fundraisers. 2) Girl Scout Cookies are a fundraiser. 3) I do not like girl scout cookies. C. 1) I do not like girl scout cookies. 2) Thin mints are girl scout cookies. 3) I do not like thin mints from there, you can use my contradiction to disprove logic. D. 1) Deductive reasoning is not flawless. 2) Deductive reasoning is a form of logic. 3) Logic is not flawless. |
« First
‹ Previous
Replies 11 - 17 of 17
|
Vermont wrote
at 4:45 PM, Thursday February 4, 2010 EST You can like one aspect of an object and dislike a different aspect.
You may like how they taste but do not like the process in which they are sold. There is no conflict here. |
|
the full monte wrote
at 6:51 PM, Thursday February 4, 2010 EST god is love. love is blind. stevie wonder is blind.
stevie wonder is god, QED, duh. |
|
skrumgaer wrote
at 6:58 PM, Thursday February 4, 2010 EST P and not P implies Q. That is sound logic. What is not sound are your 3 arguments. A1 is the P and C1 is the not P.
|
|
kekse wrote
at 7:36 PM, Thursday February 4, 2010 EST give me the cooookies!
|
|
lesplaydices wrote
at 12:12 AM, Friday February 5, 2010 EST All four of your arguments involve a fallacy of division. You fuck.
|
|
the full int wrote
at 9:45 AM, Friday February 5, 2010 EST I don't think you can make one that works.
|
|
MadHat_Sam wrote
at 9:56 AM, Friday February 5, 2010 EST This was silly.
|
