lindt truffles
sashimi
rice
eggs (i guess that means chickens too?)
cashews

imagine the ass mud coming from monte

bacon
bread
chicken
potatoes
carrots

ganj
taters
rice
corn
avacado

olive oil (can make any number of sauces, dressings with fresh herbs on island)
Milk (easy enough to make cheeses and butter)
Pig(pork, ham, bacon, ribs)
tomatoes(sauces, bbq, or fresh tomatoes)
dough(make bread, pasta, crust)

1: cow and seriously, I am leaving this island if I can't bring cow (rib eye steak,T-bone steaks,Sirloin,filet mignon,Porterhouse steaks,hamburgers,carpaccio,steak tartare, smoked salted or dried beef,milk --->cheese,yoghurt,cream,butter(aka emergency lubricant)

Again, cow is a must here. You can even use the horns to cut perfect dice to make a kdice board game. Then there is the leather that could be used for sexy outfits for my 5 picks for day 4. In some tribes they even use cow poo to make houses but I'll skip on that part of cow potential

2: potatoes (various cooking options: mash, french fries,...)
3: tomatoes (technically it's a fruit but I will need 1 vegetable)
4: eggs (mayonaise,omelet,emergency lubricant,various sauces,I'll second monte's great way around to get chicken too,+feathers to stuff my pillow)
5: lobster (just writing lobster makes me wanna put it at 2nd)

In case these 5 items will be the only things we can pick for food AND drinks, I am replacing 2 3 4 5 with wine,duvel(best belgian beer),rum,vodka

cow?
milk/cheese
bread.
olive oil!
pizza!

Good luck milking that cow with the horns........ Sounds like something les does

good point, we are not going where les has gone

I would bring the Shorthorn cows, great tasting meat, good milk, very docile animals and very importantly: without the pointy 12 inch horns

I double checked and luckily there is enough horn to make 2 dice out of one horn